The Phantom Of The Opera

I think this is their best cover in my opinion. I was always a fan of this song and when I heard Nightwish's take on it I was instantly hooked.

It's a reasonable cover i suppose. Don't think it's particularly better than the original. Tarja still does it live on her solo tour!

This song sounds amazing in combination with guitars,but the vocals are

Will not hear anything bad said against this song! It is a fantastic version and I nearly cried when I heard it live in 2005. Remarkable vocals.

The Nightwish version was the first time I'd ever heard this song, so after hearing Marco sing it any other guy singing it sounds like a woman...

I've loved this song forever! I really did think Tarja and Marco did a great job on it. I'm crushed I will never see it performed live, since Tarja is gone.

I heard it live in 2005. It was amazing and it's a shame we can't see it live again.

This song is really overrated...one of the rare songs I never listen too

It's each to their own though isn't it? I loved the song before I heard their version of it so I took to it the moment I heard it.

I love this song but I think that Tarja should gone more crazy and showed off her voice a bit more towards the end

I love this song.. but I think Marco's voice isn't great in it..

themetalinme wrote:I love this song but I think that Tarja should gone more crazy and showed off her voice a bit more towards the end

yeah,she kept too quiet... that song was a good chance to showcase her capabilities,but she didn't

I will always prefer Sarah Brightman version,with that guy whose name I can never remeber...what was his name anyway?

I think Antonia Banderas sung it with sarah Brightman... Or it could have been a dream...

Fantastic cover of a beautiful song. Gives me chills

The band did great on the music but Tarja's voice really didn't go with it. I love Tajra but The Phantom of the Opera has always been a song that use light female voices and hearing Tarja's heavy voice was just a little too much for me.

I really like it.It`s one of my favorites!I preffer it live instead of CD version

I love this one...& that one makes me cry too....It's sooooo powerful!!!
If only Anette would try to sing it...who knows...maybe she will sang it great ... maybe no .... or maybe OK!?
Pleeeeeeeassssseee Goood!!!!!!!!
I really want to see Anette singing this song

Me too.But I`m sure that will be very diffrent,because Anette`s isn`t that "operatic:as tarja.But she can hit the high notes very beautiful

yes she can! I believe in her

Me too