Do you think Nightwish were right to sack Tarja?

October 05 so nearly 4 years. I dont think it really bothered me too much and I was quite a big fan then. Just gutted me and Steph never went to the show in Brum in 05.

Yeah - I think that's all that bothers me at all, that I won't ever see NW with Tarja. Cause I probably won't go see just Tarja ever.

Same. Well I do hope to see Tarja. Dont think I'll be able to get to her London show Maybe one day she'll come to England to do a proper tour not one off shows.

I would have liked to see her with Nightwish though.

I still cry everyday because Tarja is not the vocalist of Nightwish anymore...four years mean absolutely nothing to me. I won't stop mourning until they bring her back.

Sarcasm or not? You decide

Let's weight the pro and cons of Nw without Tarja

Pro
Tarja and Nw both releasing a cd means two cds for me to love
Tarja is happier now
Nw came to Chicago, which never happened with Tarja and I didn't even have to suffer through Nemo <---- total win there even though I do actually like many live recordings of Nettie's Nemo so I make absolutely no sense
Then Tarja came to Chicago, which made my life and guess what...I got to hear Tarja sing Nemo, which made me really happy since I once thought I would never hear Tarja (or anyone for that matter) sing it live
And most importally I have gotten NEAR INFINITE entertainment from laughing at Nw and all its drama and discussing/ conspiring about various Nw related things

Cons
People were hurt
People won't get to see Tarja sing with Tuo and boys playing (which at this point I'm not sure if they'll work together period ever again...that would be sad)
Oh wait Tarja was going to quit Nw anyway, we wouldn't have seen here anyway...

So I'm pretty sure this post justifies Nw firing Tarja...What thread is this even?